Jelentés • Board Game Arena

Minden bejelentés

Keyflower bejelentései

#14859: "Cancel button in Keyflower"

awaiting: A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők

220

Miről szól ez a jelentés?

Keyflower #68638298

Mi történt? Kérünk, válassz az alábbiakból

Javaslat: szerintem a következő nagyot javítana a játék implementációján

Mi történt? Kérünk, válassz az alábbiakból

Javaslat: szerintem a következő nagyot javítana a játék implementációján

Kérjük ellenőrizd, hogy nincs-e azonos tárggyal már jelentés!

Ha igen, kérjük SZAVAZZ erre a jelentésre! A legtöbb szavazattal rendelkező jelentéssel kiemelt PRIORITÁSSAL foglalkozunk

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Részletes leírás

Bejelentés előzmények

2020. Mar 26. 22:05 • Faso • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

No suggestions

2020. Apr 28. 06:15 • Harvey Fangboner • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

It is very easy to accidentally select more workers than intended. It is very easy to use a tile rather than bid on it.

These are simple errors that would be impossible to make IRL, but they can have a major impact on the outcome of this long game.

I agree that a "confirm move" or "undo" option is necessary for this game.

2020. May 16. 15:19 • alextingle • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

This makes the game unplayable, tbh. It's a shame, because a lot of work has been put into developing it, and only a little more effort would be needed to make it playable.

2020. Jun 17. 03:32 • yomikoma • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

multiple times in my first game I saw meeples in this format:

XXX
YY

and thought "grab the uneven one off the end".

This resulted in activating a tile with 3 workers when I could have used one. Even noticing my mistake immediately, it was too late to fix it.

Requiring a "confirm" especially when using more meeples than necessary would be very welcome.

2020. Jul 22. 21:51 • gravijin • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Just played a game with my husband. I was unable to do several actions during the course of the game[102685264]. Ultimately, I lost the game as a result. Not a huge problem but it happened twice during pivotal points during the game and it is very frustrating. So frustrating that if an undo button is not implemented I would not play this game online.

2020. Jul 26. 21:49 • blahedo • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

The interaction yomikoma describes is what I came to complain about---and nearly every other player in the game also tripped over this problem at least once. The most experienced of the group said "I've played this game dozens of times here and still do that sometimes". This error is absolutely not possible to make in a F2F game, so an Undo or Cancel would be very helpful here. (Or adjust the dialog, of course.)

2020. Jul 27. 11:22 • CheekyWagwan • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

100% agree an undo last move would be helpful for all levels of players in Keyflower. Keyflower is one of those games where I find helping others to achieve with their current game feels nice and the right thing to do. So an undo would be amazing.

2020. Jul 31. 19:34 • norse • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

I was about to use two more workers on a spot I had the high bid on. I am using a touch screen, so interaction is somewhat imprecise.

Because I didn't manage to touch the middle of the tile, the game interpreted my action as bidding two additional workers - meaning I've lost the action, lost two workers and didn't gain a thing.

A "cancel" or "confirm move" button at the end would have allowed me to correct this.

(my game was 103718826, the action was intended to use 2 meeples instead of raising my bid from 2 to 4)

2020. Jul 31. 23:56 • MisterG • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

I agree that the interface would benefit from a cancel/confirm button. Too easy to make errors. I'm on a PC.

2020. Aug 7. 15:43 • Acoustic_Llama • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Also, the game selects the wrong tile sometimes when you click near the edge. An UNDO feature would allow the user to recover from this error.

2020. Sep 27. 19:58 • mitcharf • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

I completely agree that some "confirm" button should be added before any action is committed. All game should have this, but especially the longer, more complex games.

2020. Oct 3. 13:39 • Scottus • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

This game is the perfect candidate for an 'undo' or at least a 'confirm' button. The game state doesn't change and there is no new info revealed before the next player's turn. Please please please.

2020. Nov 10. 04:58 • tomjwinter • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Our last game, we had three people accidentally click on a bid tile during the Spring season, thus activating it instead of bidding on it. We restarted the game because of this. Now it happened again in our new game during the Summer season - instead of using 3 workers to outbid another player, they spent 3 workers to activate it. One bad move is enough to ruin a person's game. And it can unfairly hugely benefit another player (3 free workers next turn). Please add confirm/undo buttons after each turn.

2020. Dec 22. 19:10 • Ironmann66 • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

I've played three games and had significant issues with not being able to undo incorrect worker selection (eg picking five workers instead of one, etc). I don't see us playing this again until this is implemented.

2021. Mar 6. 04:01 • Chreotho • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Struggling with my first try at using this implementation on BGA.

How long and how many votes does it take before this gets "analyzed by the developers"?

As of March 5, 2021, the bug has been open for almost a year, since March 26, 2020, with 62 votes.

2021. Mar 19. 13:00 • unwiseowl • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Chiming in to say this game definitely needs a 'confirm action' button.

A tight game I just played was utterly rauined by three different players accidentally paying a huge number of workers to perform actions. It should be an easy fix.

2021. Mar 24. 23:43 • Johan IV • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

If you choose transport only to find out that the UI claims there are no valid transports, you can't cancel the transport.

2021. Mar 27. 06:09 • jasonbcox • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

While the suggestion is a bit broad, my specific suggestion is to undo selection of number of workers before the turn ends. It should fix most of the issues the other comments are pointing at.

We had this issue arise no less than 3 times in one game, one such misclick which directly made a player lose the game.

2021. Apr 2. 01:34 • SupaGerm • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Every time we play, at least 1 of us bids all our workers instead of the number we want. The interface just doesn't click with us, and one player accidentally dumping off 5+ workers to an opponent ruins the game for everyone. The dumper is hamstrung and the dumpee has a huge advantage.

It's 2021. Undo buttons are not a new invention!

2021. May 2. 17:59 • panaggio • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

it's too easy to make mistakes on this implementation, and most of them are really painful. It makes the experience horrible sometimes, doing the wrong thing because of a miss click or something. The interface itself is fine, the mistakes are just not because of it. Being able to undo an entire turn would be life saving.

2021. Aug 1. 11:01 • no-dude • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Please, please, please add an undo-button to this great game!!!!
Sometimes it destroys the whole strategy when you want to bid and instread - by mistake - place meaples on the tile :-(
THANKS!

2022. Jan 20. 23:33 • norse • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Just for one example: I was placing one meeple on a transport field. Instead, the game placed 5 (how is that even possible), with no way to undo. I've lost 4 meeples and an action, effectively sabotaging the game.

2022. Jan 31. 20:00 • thetedinator • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Adding my voice to all these people - BGA, you have an unplayable product on your website.

2022. Feb 11. 15:58 • n_e_s_s_u_n_o • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Hi everyone, I try to add the undo button, but I absolutely need to test it with someone that know the game better than me, and to check if I understood the request. I asked to Admin to move to private alpha so I can invite some of you to test it. Let me know if someone is interested. Thank you.

2022. Feb 27. 22:21 • 1964 Boggle Champ • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

I can help test.

2022. Apr 19. 07:10 • 1964 Boggle Champ • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Please add undo button and turn confirm. It could work the way it does on Ultimate Railroads and Russian Railroads Thank you.

2022. Jul 16. 03:18 • Seebo_dude • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

I am also willing to test if you still need testers

2023. Mar 4. 17:21 • LordWaterdeep • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

undo badly needed

2023. Oct 17. 19:50 • Luclid • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Is this still in private alpha?

2023. Nov 20. 14:55 • tmangan2 • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

When placing a tile in the final scoring, there was an option to "confirm" or "cancel". I ultimately decided that I would rather place a different tile than selected, so I used the "cancel" option. However, my tile disappeared. It's no longer available for placement. Did not work as I expected.

2024. Apr 5. 22:55 • AbleDanger • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Bumping. We REALLY need this!!!

2024. Aug 22. 12:32 • rhodery • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

For a game of this type, an Undo or at the very least a Confirm button is a necessity, especially for bidding. I like this game a lot and the overall play is great, but the extremely unforgiving nature of the interface inclines me to not waste me time with it.

2025. Sep 30. 00:26 • redmoon6584 • A javaslatot még nem vizsgálták meg a fejlesztők:

Would really like an undo button, as it is very helpful in other games. Accidental clicks or mistakes could be easily corrected without wasting a turn. Would like the option for steps within an action and actions. Thanks for your consideration!

Hozzáadni valamit a jelentéshez

Kérjük adj meg itt bármit, ami fontos a hiba reprodukálásához vagy a javaslat megértéséhez:

Másik asztal ID / lépés ID
az F5 megoldotta a problémát?
Milyen gyakran jön elő a probléma? Minden alkalommal? Véletlenszerűen?
Ha van screenshot-od erről a bugról (ajánlott), használd a Imgur.com, hogy feltöltsd, majd másold be a linket.

Mégse Jelentés frissítése

#14859: "Cancel button in Keyflower"

Miről szól ez a jelentés?

Mi történt? Kérünk, válassz az alábbiakból

Mi történt? Kérünk, válassz az alábbiakból

Kérjük ellenőrizd, hogy nincs-e azonos tárggyal már jelentés!

Részletes leírás

Bejelentés előzmények

Hozzáadni valamit a jelentéshez

Változtasd meg a bejelentés státuszát erre:

Segítség

Hozzájárulás

Navigáció

Kövess bennünket