Minden bejelentés
Catan Telepesei bejelentései
#86468: "Longest road was not applied"
Tisch #689495883
Zug #388
Fortschritt 100%
Longest Road not working
Zug'# 384 - 388
Nach versetzen des Ritters wurde die Dtrasse nicht als längste erkannt
#86468: "Longest road was not applied"
infoneeded: További információkra lenne szüksége a fejlesztőknek a bug előidézéséhez
86468
51
Miről szól ez a jelentés?
Mi történt? Kérünk, válassz az alábbiakból
Szabályok: A játék szabályának be nem tartása
Mi történt? Kérünk, válassz az alábbiakból
Szabályok: A játék szabályának be nem tartása
Kérjük ellenőrizd, hogy nincs-e azonos tárggyal már jelentés!
Ha igen, kérjük SZAVAZZ erre a jelentésre! A legtöbb szavazattal rendelkező jelentéssel kiemelt PRIORITÁSSAL foglalkozunk
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Részletes leírás
-
• Kérjük másold be a hiba üzenetet, amit kaptál, ha volt ilyen.
ended up having to play until 12 points because the longest road was not given
-
• Kérjük mondd el, hogy mit szerettél volna csinálni, mit csináltál és mi történt
Yes, but not sure how to find it
• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v111
-
• Kérjük, másold az angolul megjelenített szöveget, ahelyett, hogy lefordítanád a Te nyelvedre! Ha van erről a hibáról képernyőképed (ami ajánlott), bármilyen képfeltöltő oldalra feltöltheted (snipboard.io például) a feltöltéshez másold ki a linket és illeszd be ide. Létezik ez a szöveg a fordítási rendszerben? Ha igen, több mint 24 órája lett lefordítva?
ended up having to play until 12 points because the longest road was not given
• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v111
-
• Kérjük magyarázd el a javaslatodat pontosan és tömören, hogy amennyire lehet, könnyen érthető legyen, mire is gondolsz!
ended up having to play until 12 points because the longest road was not given
• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v111
-
• Mit láttál a képernyőn, amikor blokkolva lettél? (Üres képernyő? A játék felületének egy részét? Hiba üzenet?)
ended up having to play until 12 points because the longest road was not given
• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v111
-
• A szabályok melyik részét nem vette figyelembe a BGA adaptáció
ended up having to play until 12 points because the longest road was not given
-
• Ez a szabály áthágása látható a visszajátszásban? Ha igen, melyik lépésszámnál?
Yes, but not sure how to find it
• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v111
-
• Melyik játékbeli akciót akartad csinálni, amikor a hiba előjött?
ended up having to play until 12 points because the longest road was not given
-
• Mit akartál csinálni, hogy ezt a játékbeli akciót elindíthasd?
Yes, but not sure how to find it
-
• Mi történt amikor megpróbáltad ezt (hiba üzenet, játék státusz üzenet, ...)?
• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v111
-
• A játék melyik lépésénél lépett fel a probléma? (mi volt a kiírt utasítás?)
ended up having to play until 12 points because the longest road was not given
-
• Mi történt amikor megpróbáltad ezt az akciót (hiba üzenet, játék státusz üzenet, ...)?
Yes, but not sure how to find it
• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v111
-
• Kérjük, írd le a megjelenítési hibát! Ha van erről a hibáról képernyőképed (ami ajánlott), bármilyen képfeltöltő oldalra feltöltheted (snipboard.io például) a feltöltéshez másold ki a linket és illeszd be ide.
ended up having to play until 12 points because the longest road was not given
• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v111
-
• Kérjük, másold az angolul megjelenített szöveget, ahelyett, hogy lefordítanád a Te nyelvedre! Ha van erről a hibáról képernyőképed (ami ajánlott), bármilyen képfeltöltő oldalra feltöltheted (snipboard.io például) a feltöltéshez másold ki a linket és illeszd be ide. Létezik ez a szöveg a fordítási rendszerben? Ha igen, több mint 24 órája lett lefordítva?
ended up having to play until 12 points because the longest road was not given
• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v111
-
• Kérjük magyarázd el a javaslatodat pontosan és tömören, hogy amennyire lehet, könnyen érthető legyen, mire is gondolsz!
ended up having to play until 12 points because the longest road was not given
• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v111
Bejelentés előzmények
2023. Apr 17. 01:19 • Bionic Limbs • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
i do not know how to check that
2023. Jul 28. 21:25 • MM22MM • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Ik heb 12 aansluitende straten gebouwd, maar kreeg geen langste route punten.
Tafel #401560680
F5 loste het probleem niet op.
Ik heb dit probleem voor het eerst.
Tafel #401560680
F5 loste het probleem niet op.
Ik heb dit probleem voor het eerst.
2024. Jun 7. 22:36 • rainbowsinhereyes • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
near the end of the game CATAN #522455835 .roads werent counted when opponents knight removed, then when got longest road despite this i still didnt get the points.
2024. Jun 10. 10:18 • ChaosMoonGem • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Longest Road wasn't switched when a blocking knight was removed via the Deserter card.
2024. Jun 13. 18:14 • Dettispielt • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
After playing "Intrigue" - the street counter for Yellow shows 5, but the real street has nine pieces
imgur.com/sWofrqS
imgur.com/sWofrqS
2024. Jun 15. 21:54 • papury • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
At the end of the game I remove knight of another player and recover my longest road.. however points did not change and the other player kept having longest road and won.. rules not followed
2024. Jun 19. 05:57 • NnSshared • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
CATAN #525804366
Same as what others have reported, blue played intrigue to remove an orange knight blocking longest road. The game still acts as if the knight is still blocking.
Same as what others have reported, blue played intrigue to remove an orange knight blocking longest road. The game still acts as if the knight is still blocking.
2024. Jun 19. 11:16 • emce • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
boardgamearena.com/11/catan?table=527099110&replayFrom=460
Table ID: 527099110
Move ID (not sure if correct): 460
F5/refresh did not resolve problem, it must be server side issue.
Blue has played Intrigue card to remove my knight splitting his road. After my knifht was removed, he still did not get back Longest Route card and points. Road length was not updated as you can see on screenshot. I am still holding Longest Route card.
imgur.com/a/Grd4qAU
Table ID: 527099110
Move ID (not sure if correct): 460
F5/refresh did not resolve problem, it must be server side issue.
Blue has played Intrigue card to remove my knight splitting his road. After my knifht was removed, he still did not get back Longest Route card and points. Road length was not updated as you can see on screenshot. I am still holding Longest Route card.
imgur.com/a/Grd4qAU
2024. Jun 30. 20:32 • Avelon • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
boardgamearena.com/table?table=531427841
I didn't see this last night when I posted my own report:
boardgamearena.com/bug?id=128986
It might be useful to clarify if this is also happening in the base game, for example when the Longest Road holder's road is bisected by a settlement and the other players are eligible but tied for Longest Road.
My experience was with a knight moving off of a road intersection and then that new road length not being correctly counted.
I didn't see this last night when I posted my own report:
boardgamearena.com/bug?id=128986
It might be useful to clarify if this is also happening in the base game, for example when the Longest Road holder's road is bisected by a settlement and the other players are eligible but tied for Longest Road.
My experience was with a knight moving off of a road intersection and then that new road length not being correctly counted.
2024. Jul 6. 00:39 • repke77 • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Ik mocht twee straten bouwen, waardoor twee losse stukken route aan elkaar werden gevoegd als 1 lange route.
Dit telde het spel niet als 1 lange straat
Dit telde het spel niet als 1 lange straat
2024. Jul 28. 04:25 • djabwana • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
There are also longest road bugs with the Diplomat card
2024. Aug 6. 23:15 • Isa_2607 • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
My road was 14 and I lost two points against an opponent with less than 14 !
2024. Sep 15. 22:46 • pikitator • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
J'avais une route séparée en deux par un chevalier ennemi. Lors du déplacement du chevalier, le calcul de la route la plus longue n'a pas été réalisé. Y compris après remplacement du chevalier par une colonie. Calcul fait à nouveau lors de l'ajout d'une route.
2024. Nov 24. 22:02 • SvenOver • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Table ID: boardgamearena.com/4/catan?table=593301078
Imgur link: imgur.com/a/z1pf4Ui
F5 didn't solve the problem.
Red voluntarily withdraw his knight of strength 2 from the blue route in southern direction, therefore no longer blocking blue route. Blue route was of length 5 then, but this wasn't updated (it still displayed 4) and the 2 points were not awarded (4 should be 6), although the routes of all others were less long. See 1st image of the imgur link above.
Only when I build 6th road, the length was calculated correctly (6) and the 2 points were rewarded (6 points). See 2nd image of the imgur link above.
SOLUTION: recalculate route lengths also after knight replacements.
CAN I HELP YOU WITH THE (PSEUDO-) CODE AND PROGRAMMING?
Imgur link: imgur.com/a/z1pf4Ui
F5 didn't solve the problem.
Red voluntarily withdraw his knight of strength 2 from the blue route in southern direction, therefore no longer blocking blue route. Blue route was of length 5 then, but this wasn't updated (it still displayed 4) and the 2 points were not awarded (4 should be 6), although the routes of all others were less long. See 1st image of the imgur link above.
Only when I build 6th road, the length was calculated correctly (6) and the 2 points were rewarded (6 points). See 2nd image of the imgur link above.
SOLUTION: recalculate route lengths also after knight replacements.
CAN I HELP YOU WITH THE (PSEUDO-) CODE AND PROGRAMMING?
2024. Nov 26. 20:52 • smartin23 • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
boardgamearena.com/3/catan?table=591042479
I got the longest road - without having it.
I lost the longest road due to a knight. When I tried to take it back, I got it with 5 roads despite my opponnents have 6 roads.
It instantly ended the game.
(Luckely I would have ended it anyway)
I got the longest road - without having it.
I lost the longest road due to a knight. When I tried to take it back, I got it with 5 roads despite my opponnents have 6 roads.
It instantly ended the game.
(Luckely I would have ended it anyway)
2024. Dec 3. 13:35 • klouttch • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
same as smartin23, I took of a knight to let the road to the other opponent but it stayed to the guy who add the road before even if the other one got longest road at that time. Then he won, but he should not have had the 2 points of the road
2024. Dec 8. 18:32 • rainbowsinhereyes • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Table #599220390
2025. Jan 20. 08:28 • RoyalRatAuthority • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
I have been experiencing this bug a ton in Cities and Knights. If someone recalls their knight that was bisecting another's road, longest road is not re-calculated (often leading to the player with the shorter road keeping the longest road card). If the player who should have longest road adds another segment to their road, only then is longest road re-distributed.
2025. Jan 26. 17:36 • Athanoral • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
The Longest Road victory point is not being awarded to the player with the numerically longest road.
Steps to Reproduce:
Player B has 7 connected road segments
Player A has Longest Road card with 8 connected roads
Player B builds a house that breaks Player A's road
Player A's road is reduced to 4 segments
Player A builds one road, reaching 5 segments
System incorrectly awards Longest Road to Player A (5 segments) instead of Player B (7 segments)
Expected Behavior:
The Longest Road card should be awarded to the player with the highest number of connected road segments (Player B with 7).
Additional Notes:
The road segment counter correctly displays the numbers (7 vs 5)
The victory point assignment logic appears to be disconnected from the road length displayed
Steps to Reproduce:
Player B has 7 connected road segments
Player A has Longest Road card with 8 connected roads
Player B builds a house that breaks Player A's road
Player A's road is reduced to 4 segments
Player A builds one road, reaching 5 segments
System incorrectly awards Longest Road to Player A (5 segments) instead of Player B (7 segments)
Expected Behavior:
The Longest Road card should be awarded to the player with the highest number of connected road segments (Player B with 7).
Additional Notes:
The road segment counter correctly displays the numbers (7 vs 5)
The victory point assignment logic appears to be disconnected from the road length displayed
2025. Jan 26. 17:37 • Athanoral • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Table : CATAN #367827850
2025. Mar 5. 01:31 • Mikesk • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Another player had longest road of 9, I added few roads, and connected 2 separate roads from different settlement routss, became 10 roads, but I didn't get longest road bonus, and should win, but lost.
2025. Mar 18. 15:48 • ejohnston • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
I also didn't get the longest road card in my game.
Table #645476085
I had a road length of 7.
Table #645476085
I had a road length of 7.
2025. Apr 1. 21:47 • AndyJames63 • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
This was a knights and cities game. The winner had a 5 street road, and we both had 7, but the winner was given the longest road card. Their road had been interrupted by a Knight.
2025. Apr 23. 23:17 • Coisinho • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
F5 did not solve. The road card should have changed hands.
2025. May 21. 20:39 • FromLardToHard • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
The Longest Road was not transferred to the person with the most roads.
2025. May 21. 20:44 • FromLardToHard • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
CATAN #367827850 roads werent counted when opponents knight removed,
Move 271 :12:36:34 PM
FromLardToHard builds a settlement for lumber,brick,wool,grain
Move 272 :12:36:40 PM
FromLardToHard moves a knight
Knight is now inactive
Move 273 :12:36:53 PM
FromLardToHard passes
Move 274 :12:36:54 PM
Liliaus rolls dice: 6,5,Science
Liliaus gets lumber,wool,cloth
maggieswaggie gets nothing
FromLardToHard gets lumber,paper
Move 271 :12:36:34 PM
FromLardToHard builds a settlement for lumber,brick,wool,grain
Move 272 :12:36:40 PM
FromLardToHard moves a knight
Knight is now inactive
Move 273 :12:36:53 PM
FromLardToHard passes
Move 274 :12:36:54 PM
Liliaus rolls dice: 6,5,Science
Liliaus gets lumber,wool,cloth
maggieswaggie gets nothing
FromLardToHard gets lumber,paper
2025. May 24. 12:34 • RomainJ • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Playing vanilla Catan, the longest road was cut by a colony of my opponent, giving me the longest road. The system gave me only one point instead of 2.
Table #677707555
Coup #231
Progression 100%
Table #677707555
Coup #231
Progression 100%
2025. Jun 18. 15:28 • CaptainDex • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Tisch #689495883
Zug #388
Fortschritt 100%
Longest Road not working
Zug'# 384 - 388
Nach versetzen des Ritters wurde die Dtrasse nicht als längste erkannt
2025. Aug 4. 23:11 • Hindemith11 • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Table #710578169
Move #260
I got a road of length 5 and won, getting two points, although another player had already a road of length 5 (maybe he didnt get the longest road back after a knight was removed from his 5 long road?
Move #260
I got a road of length 5 and won, getting two points, although another player had already a road of length 5 (maybe he didnt get the longest road back after a knight was removed from his 5 long road?
2025. Sep 4. 02:46 • Altchar • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
imgur.com/a/yraXRjH
I had 10 roads but did not get longest road, which persisted with the blue player.
I had 10 roads but did not get longest road, which persisted with the blue player.
2025. Sep 12. 20:27 • juzzzzz • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
i removed the knight and the longest road should have gone to orange. It didn't
2025. Sep 17. 17:10 • La Koschka • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
After an oponent removed his knight, my road was the longest but the display didn't change and i didnt get the longest road.
2025. Sep 30. 19:39 • Paradox Raider • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
I already reported this to support@ as soon as it happened yesterday but please below. I have a screenshot which I will add to using imgur as mentioned above.
Please could you review the game logs for Catan game "boardgamearena.com/table?table=736748558". I should have won the game, but it didn't give me the longest road and therefore the win. Screenshot below of final move.
I had 8 points already and knew I had won on my final go as I can 14 cards, so I built a city to get to 9 pts (to get to 11 pts in total) and then built 3 roads as per screenshot below which should have taken me to 8 roads therefore surpassing TW1003's 7 road, but it didn't give me the longest road and the win and as I had no idea what was happening, my time started to run down, I panicked and rolled back my move to try to get 4 more roads (so 9 roads in total) to make sure then I think someone kicked me out of the game as they knew I had won.
Can you review it please, as pretty sure a game glitch and not only did I lose 26 elo points taking me down to 257 elo, but it also reduced my Arena Elite ranking from 663rd all the way down to 926th when I made the correct moves to win the game by 11 pts.
Please could you review the game logs for Catan game "boardgamearena.com/table?table=736748558". I should have won the game, but it didn't give me the longest road and therefore the win. Screenshot below of final move.
I had 8 points already and knew I had won on my final go as I can 14 cards, so I built a city to get to 9 pts (to get to 11 pts in total) and then built 3 roads as per screenshot below which should have taken me to 8 roads therefore surpassing TW1003's 7 road, but it didn't give me the longest road and the win and as I had no idea what was happening, my time started to run down, I panicked and rolled back my move to try to get 4 more roads (so 9 roads in total) to make sure then I think someone kicked me out of the game as they knew I had won.
Can you review it please, as pretty sure a game glitch and not only did I lose 26 elo points taking me down to 257 elo, but it also reduced my Arena Elite ranking from 663rd all the way down to 926th when I made the correct moves to win the game by 11 pts.
2025. Sep 30. 19:45 • Paradox Raider • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
For the above ticket, it is not letting me upload my screenshot to Imgur as it is saying this content isn't available in my region. Please could you get Emma from support@ to forward my email to her from yesterday to you which has the screenshot which clearly shows there is an issue with the game in those circumstances.
2025. Oct 3. 09:03 • raspberryoolong • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
We also saw this issue at this table: boardgamearena.com/table?table=738320255
Originally Bill Y had the longest road. At move 428, I cut his road, so Kudra777 and I were tied for 7 roads with nobody having the longest road. At move 458, Bill removed the knight that was breaking Kudra's road, so Kudra should have gotten the longest road with 11 roads. It did not assign, and I was able to take longest road with fewer than Kudra at move 473
Originally Bill Y had the longest road. At move 428, I cut his road, so Kudra777 and I were tied for 7 roads with nobody having the longest road. At move 458, Bill removed the knight that was breaking Kudra's road, so Kudra should have gotten the longest road with 11 roads. It did not assign, and I was able to take longest road with fewer than Kudra at move 473
2025. Oct 4. 13:21 • Old_Man_Joe • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Another player won as the longest road wasn't applied when knight was moved
2025. Dec 18. 16:38 • tallerer • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
it was a strange situation.... the longest road got cut in half, but was then given to the person with the shortest road (3 of us had 6, and one had 5- the person with 5 got the longest road)
2025. Dec 28. 05:42 • TacticalTableShow • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
snipboard.io/SC9Geq.jpg Map
snipboard.io/C231VG.jpg Log
Longest road does not apply if an opponent has a settlement that intersects with the longest road. I had the longest road and lost it from the orange player placing a settlement on bottom right 12 ore, 6 ore, 3 wood intersection
snipboard.io/C231VG.jpg Log
Longest road does not apply if an opponent has a settlement that intersects with the longest road. I had the longest road and lost it from the orange player placing a settlement on bottom right 12 ore, 6 ore, 3 wood intersection
2025. Dec 29. 10:13 • darhf • További információkra lenne szüksége a fejlesztőknek a bug előidézéséhez:
TacticalTableShow => Settlements cut the longest road. The 7 length on the screenshot is correct.
2025. Dec 29. 10:37 • TacticalTableShow • További információkra lenne szüksége a fejlesztőknek a bug előidézéséhez:
You are correct. I had never thought of it. Made me have to the Catan Almanac. I don't think the scenario came up before or we overlooked it playing in person with no computer to automatically negotiate. Appreciate it.
Longest road from almanac
snipboard.io/sp8BOk.jpg
Longest road from almanac
snipboard.io/sp8BOk.jpg
2025. Dec 29. 11:27 • SvenOver • További információkra lenne szüksége a fejlesztőknek a bug előidézéséhez:
@darfh: perhaps you can have a look at other messages above that do show images of wrong route length calculations? They have to do with moved knights which do no longer split up someones road
2026. Jan 12. 20:51 • Katie_mi • További információkra lenne szüksége a fejlesztőknek a bug előidézéséhez:
snipboard.io/JSTHOu.jpg
Yellow player has 5 roads first but kept longest road though blue player had 6 roads
boardgamearena.com/13/catan?table=789010974
Yellow player has 5 roads first but kept longest road though blue player had 6 roads
boardgamearena.com/13/catan?table=789010974
2026. Jan 12. 22:11 • Phoxtrot • További információkra lenne szüksége a fejlesztőknek a bug előidézéséhez:
For kate_mi 789010974, it's a visual bug. Did you try F5 because in the replay, yellow has road size 6.
imgur.com/LW7BMsq
imgur.com/LW7BMsq
Hozzáadni valamit a jelentéshez
Kérjük adj meg itt bármit, ami fontos a hiba reprodukálásához vagy a javaslat megértéséhez:
- Másik asztal ID / lépés ID
- az F5 megoldotta a problémát?
- Milyen gyakran jön elő a probléma? Minden alkalommal? Véletlenszerűen?
- Ha van erről a hibáról képernyőképed (ami ajánlott), bármilyen képfeltöltő oldalra feltöltheted (snipboard.io például) a feltöltéshez másold ki a linket és illeszd be ide.
Változtasd meg a bejelentés státuszát erre:
bug?id=86468
