Minden bejelentés
Pandemic bejelentései
#50381: "Game ended before player draw deck exhausted"
Miről szól ez a jelentés?
Mi történt? Kérünk, válassz az alábbiakból
Szabályok: A játék szabályának be nem tartása
Részletes leírás
• A szabályok melyik részét nem vette figyelembe a BGA adaptáció
The UI shows there are 3 cards remaining the player draw. When I attempted to draw cards at the end of my player's turn, it says the game is lost because "There are not enough cards in player draw". Either the UI is wrong or the game ended prematurely.• Ez a szabály áthágása látható a visszajátszásban? Ha igen, melyik lépésszámnál?
no, after game replay the UI is updated to show only 1 card remaining now. This is a very misleading UI bug that can have a huge impact on decision-making in Pandemic.• Milyen böngészőt használsz?
Google Chrome v94
Bejelentés előzmények
2021. okt 10. 11:04 • davidt23 • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
2021. okt 10. 14:02 • diamant • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
There are 59 Player cards in the box, including 48 City cards, 5 Event cards and 6 Epidemic cards. At the beginning of a game, the draw pile must contain 59 cards minus 4 cards per specialist, therefore 51 cards in this game. However, the number displayed is 53 in the referenced game.
At move #167, all the Epidemic cards were drawn and resolved, so removed from the game. So there are only 53 cards left in the draw pile, in the discard pile and in the hands of the specialists.
But I note:
Draw pile: 5
Discard pile: 36
Researcher: 7
Medic: 7
Total: 55 cards therefore 2 surplus cards. This count is still wrong at the end of the game.
The conclusion is that the displayed account of cards for the Player draw pile is erroneous throughout the game. This bug should be corrected.
At move #167, all the Epidemic cards were drawn and resolved, so removed from the game. So there are only 53 cards left in the draw pile, in the discard pile and in the hands of the specialists.
But I note:
Draw pile: 5
Discard pile: 36
Researcher: 7
Medic: 7
Total: 55 cards therefore 2 surplus cards. This count is still wrong at the end of the game.
The conclusion is that the displayed account of cards for the Player draw pile is erroneous throughout the game. This bug should be corrected.
2021. nov 4. 11:26 • Qualitaetsgarant • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
2021. dec 2. 21:48 • Biking Gamer • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Had similar problem, only more severe occur in table #220895979. imgur.com/gallery/s4kix6u
Screen shows 5 cards left in deck, but when a player draws cards the message "There are not enough cards in player draw" displays. This is visible in the replay.
Also in the replay, the first turn shows there are 53 cards in the deck but no epidemics. Once the cards are drawn at end of the first player turn it shows 5 epidemics and 51 cards in deck. (I don't know if this happened at beginning of the game - I didn't notice the count at that time.) So it appears that the count is wrong from the beginning of the game. It should be:
48 city cards
5 epidemic cards (for standard game)
5 event cards
---------------------
58 total cards
So it is short by 5 cards.
Screen shows 5 cards left in deck, but when a player draws cards the message "There are not enough cards in player draw" displays. This is visible in the replay.
Also in the replay, the first turn shows there are 53 cards in the deck but no epidemics. Once the cards are drawn at end of the first player turn it shows 5 epidemics and 51 cards in deck. (I don't know if this happened at beginning of the game - I didn't notice the count at that time.) So it appears that the count is wrong from the beginning of the game. It should be:
48 city cards
5 epidemic cards (for standard game)
5 event cards
---------------------
58 total cards
So it is short by 5 cards.
2023. febr 19. 12:38 • DanaAna • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Problem appears several times, game finishes though there are still 5 cards in the draw
2023. febr 20. 14:48 • Qualitaetsgarant • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Another version
2023. jún 7. 18:05 • SWORDONE • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
「ターンをやり直す」を押すと、その時点での正しい山札の枚数に直るようです。
2023. júl 9. 17:52 • SarahNorth • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Table ID 395100274
After losing my previous game due to this bug, I decided to check the deck # at the beginning of my next game. It’s showing 53, but with 9 cards already in the hands of the three roles, it should be showing 50.
i.imgur.com/lW0RHiH.jpg
After losing my previous game due to this bug, I decided to check the deck # at the beginning of my next game. It’s showing 53, but with 9 cards already in the hands of the three roles, it should be showing 50.
i.imgur.com/lW0RHiH.jpg
2023. nov 1. 23:48 • mdlake • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
I have repeatedly experienced what Biking Gamer and DanaAna have, but I believe the player deck is in fact exhausted but has failed to keep the deck count accurate, ending the game while reporting 5 cards remaining. It's an ugly surprise, but hand-counting after my own solitaire game, all the cards are accounted for.
2024. jan 22. 6:44 • Fermat78 • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Like others, ended unexpectedly with 5 cards displayed as remaining in the deck.
2024. febr 28. 15:20 • andrekowal • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
As others, it ended unexpectedly with 5 cards displayed as remaining in the deck:
boardgamearena.com/5/pandemic?table=480947767
boardgamearena.com/5/pandemic?table=480947767
2024. febr 29. 15:44 • andrekowal • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Again, same problem, 5 cards left and end of game: boardgamearena.com/bug?id=0&table=481360327
2024. márc 3. 7:17 • Fermat78 • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Table #482460396
Move #154
Progression 100%
Game ended at 5 cards
Move #154
Progression 100%
Game ended at 5 cards
2024. márc 31. 0:53 • Clarenah • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
boardgamearena.com/10/pandemic?table=493850344
had a similar issue, near the end of the game the discard showed 5 cards remaining, then suddenly went down to 3 within the same turn/before cards were drawn
had a similar issue, near the end of the game the discard showed 5 cards remaining, then suddenly went down to 3 within the same turn/before cards were drawn
2025. jan 12. 18:03 • amber_missy • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
Same - 5 left in the deck, but game ended early:
imgur.com/a/R8Rhone
boardgamearena.com/table?table=614415147
imgur.com/a/R8Rhone
boardgamearena.com/table?table=614415147
2025. márc 5. 17:01 • jortlesplus • A hibát még nem tudták reprodukálni a fejlesztők:
This exact same thing happened to me (3 cards shown remaining - which is wrong anyway because only even numbers of the player draw cards is possible each turn since you draw in increments of 2 - and then it said I lost the game with no player cards remaining).
Hozzáadni valamit a jelentéshez
Kérjük adj meg itt bármit, ami fontos a hiba reprodukálásához vagy a javaslat megértéséhez:
- Másik asztal ID / lépés ID
- az F5 megoldotta a problémát?
- Milyen gyakran jön elő a probléma? Minden alkalommal? Véletlenszerűen?
- Ha van screenshot-od erről a bugról (ajánlott), használd a Imgur.com, hogy feltöltsd, majd másold be a linket.
